The West’s errant conception of China

The Western mainstream media has a field day in the 19th Chinese Party congress that is currently being held in Beijing. All sorts of half-truths and innuendoes were apparently made to cast Chinese leadership under Xi Jinping in very bad light. For example, BBC reported that a million people were jailed under Xi Jinping in a purge. Actually, according to local media the anti-corruption drive merely punished 1 million errant party members and officials in the anti-corruption campaign over the years. There was no mention of jail sentencing. Thus majority would likely receive warnings, pay deduction, fines etc, rather than imprisonment. Hence, the once almighty Western media is slowly and surely losing its grips on news monopoly as most people can see how ridiculous and desperate they have become. Relying on the Western media for information will likely to reinforce the ‘frog in the well’ outlook.

Below is CGTN Liu Xin’s diatribe of Western media, which is rarely seen from a Chinese TV host. Nevertheless, it is high time now that more assertive Chinese voice is heard on the bad behavior of the purveyor of fake news, aka the Western mainstream media.

Getting To The Point: What’s wrong with this western story about China?

Source:Global Times Published: 2017/10/20 22:38:39

The West’s errant conception of China
China has entered a new era in building socialism with Chinese characteristics. The 19th National Congress of the Communist Party of China has mapped out plans for the new era. The Western media is taking great interest in what is happening in China and many mainstream media outlets in the US and Europe have given a lot of coverage of the event to cater to the public need. But some Western journalists do not show professionalism in their coverage and their reporting remains ideologically superficial and does not get the gist of China’s new era.

The Western media’s coverage of China in recent years generally recognizes the basic fact of China’s development and changes but their understanding misses the point of the true nature of China’s development. Their perception of China’s development path and future is absolute and lacks openness. They don’t want to see China’s success and such a subjective conception has penetrated the whole process in their understanding of China and led to their conclusion that China will not succeed.

We must admit that the Western media’s observation and analysis of China have erred. As a result, their perception of China is misleading, based on the following gauges.

First, they believe that the closer China’s development path and political goals get to the West’s political system and development model, the more China is on the right path. Once they believe China shows signs of diverging from the Western path and moving ahead faster, they consider it a wrong, dangerous direction.

Second, they believe that China’s development should focus on consolidating the West’s vested interests or helping the West safeguard their interests. China can have its own interests but China’s interests should not override those of the West and attempt to change the current world order. Otherwise, China’s development is deemed negative and challenges the world order.

Third, they believe that China’s development should not challenge the “universal values” upheld by the West. So-called universal values refer to the value system formed during the process of development of Western society, which actually parallels the continuous expansion of Western interests. Therefore, in reality and in international politics, “universal values” have to a large extent integrated with Western interests. The clashes of other value systems with “universal values” constitute an offense against Western interests. The further Western interests expand, the more frequently a clash occurs with different value systems. This becomes a major problem between China and the West.

Humanity’s knowledge and experience of self-governance is still deficient. It is impossible to establish an absolute criterion to gauge which development path is superior to the other. Instead it can only be tested by practice. In other words, the only criterion to assess China’s development path is whether it can contribute to the rapid progress of China and whether it can allow the general public to share the dividend of the country’s progress. International factors can also be considered. But such a gauge must focus on whether China’s development contributes to world peace. Factors such as whether the West appreciates or applauds China’s progress should not be given priority.

Generally speaking, public opinion in the West toward China’s rapid development is very complicated. This is understandable. The Western media’s conception of China represents their sentiment in the West which is far from having adapted to China’s rise. Their anxiety over China’s rise leads to their paranoia and unreasonable belief that “the West is all right and China is all wrong.” The influence of the Western press used to be overwhelming but the internal chaos and divide in the West weakens their position. The influence of the Western press is shrinking.

China in the new era is more and more confident. The breathless pace of development and ever-changing dynamics over the past decades reinforce China’s confidence. China can only succeed by following the path that is in line with its national condition. China cannot replicate others’ experience, particularly with its political system. This is the consensus of Chinese society. Therefore the incorrect coverage of China by the Western press can only mislead its own society and its disturbing influence on China is increasingly diluted.

Advertisements

About kchew

an occasional culturalist
This entry was posted in China view. Bookmark the permalink.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s