Why I hardly read the SMH

I came across this article while reading the Sydney Morning Herald. I hardly read SMH nowadays, but made an exception just to read the Australian financial market reaction to the Lehman Bros crisis.
But another artcle caught my attention. This is the accusation that Chinese authorities have hushed up the milk scandal. Whenever there is a tragedy that happens in China, one should not be surprised at how the Western reporters earn their dues in maligning China.
This article really should be in the on tabloid journalism category. The reporter should take a course in logical reasoning, before coming up with such lame excuses to blame the Chinese government. The Olympics ended more than 2 weeks ago, and logically speaking, the scandal should then appear 2 weeks earlier. The so called directives being issued by Chinese government is obviously an imaginary one. Even if it is real, there are just too many people with internet access and the different type of media that will bring it out to the surface. Some of the Western reporters are just plain dumb, or it is just a case of negative news about China will ensure that they get printed in the papers and they will be paid more for their dirty works.
Was China’s milk scandal hushed up?

Stephen Hutcheon
September 15, 2008 – 4:41PM

Did Chinese authorities put off a decision to issue a nationwide recall of contaminated milk powder in August, that has since claimed the lives of two babies, for the sake of the Olympics?

That is one conclusion being drawn after it was revealed that Sanlu, the Chinese company that produced and sold the tainted powder was advised to issue a recall as far back as August 2 – six days before the opening of the Beijing Olympics.

That was the day Fonterra, the New Zealand co-operative which owns a minority stake in Sanlu, said it was both informed about the contamination and advised the Sanlu board to make a full recall.

"From the day that we were advised of the product contamination issue in August, Fonterra called for a full public recall of all affected product," the company said in statement issued on Sunday.

A full recall of 700 tonnes of the tainted milk powder, which was found to contain traces of the chemical melamine, was made only on September 11 – six weeks after the alarm was raised.

Melamine, a white powdery substance in its raw form, is used in the manufacture of fabric, glue, housewares and flame retardants.

Chinese health authorities are reporting that almost 500 babies have fallen ill after drinking the tainted milk.

More than 430 of the affected children – many of whom come from families living in impoverished regions of the country – are suffering from kidney stones caused by the chemical.

Exactly why the alarm was not raised before last week is still unclear. Neither Fonterra nor Sanlu are answering questions.

Fonterra has issued a statement saying it was not in a position to make any further comments about the case as an investigation was under way.

In the lead-up to the Olympics, China’s Central Propaganda Department issued a 21-point directive to the local media, detailing the ground rules for reporting during the Games.

It included no-go zones such as pro-independence movements in Tibet and the restive Muslim province of Xinjiang and regional territorial disputes, but also included instructions on how to report sporting successes modestly.

The existence of the list was first reported by the South China Morning Post, Hong Kong’s leading English-language newspaper.

But it was The Sydney Morning Herald’s Jacquelin Magnay who obtained an English translation of the directive and published it on August 14.

Point 8 of the directive states: "All food safety issues, such as cancer-causing mineral water, is off-limits."

Chinese authorities subsequently denied such a directive existed.

China regularly issues directives on news coverage.

In 2005, the Chinese journalist Shi Tao was sentenced to 10 years imprisonment for leaking details of a similar directive to local media on how to cover the 15th anniversary of the Tiananmen Square massacre.

Chinese authorities say 19 people have been detained and 78 are being questioned over the contamination scandal.

Sanlu is China’s biggest milk-powder producer and one of the country’s "big six" Chinese dairies.

The official English-language China Daily newspaper today quotes Li Changjiang, minister of the General Administration of Quality Supervision, Inspection and Quarantine, saying that investigations were focusing on milk collecting stations.

The 19 detained people held in connection with the case were from private milk collecting stations, he said.

– with agencies


About kchew

an occasional culturalist
This entry was posted in China view. Bookmark the permalink.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s